Peter Schmuck

Peter Schmuck: The MLB lockout looms, but it won’t mean anything to you until March

So, on December 1st, Major League Baseball is expected to declare a lockout in hopes of pressuring the Major League Baseball Players Association into accepting a hard salary cap.

Since no one is denying that, you’re going to have to prepare yourself for months of boring labor news, which will feature the same salary cap arguments and rebuttals that have been used since the game was shut down for two months in 1981.

The owners need something they used to call “cost certainty.” The players are pretty certain that it’s really just that the owners are – as they have long been – horrified by their own inability to control those costs, as evidenced by the fact that they are three-quarters of the way to the first $1 billion free-agent contract.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

That leaves baseball fans to decide whether to root for the billionaires or the hundred-milionaires as they wait to see if the 2027 season is either delayed or lost.

It certainly wasn’t comforting when Commissioner Rob Manfred made it clear – sort of – that the owners are not going to settle for anything less than a hard cap that would limit teams to a maximum payroll of $284.2 million and include a payroll floor of $180.2 million. He seemed to indicate that there might be some wiggle room as far as the actual numbers are concerned but the cap would go into effect in 2028.

I have just one question on the amounts. What’s up with the point two at the end of each figure? Is that the tip?

I was a 24-year-old rookie California Angels beat writer when I witnessed my first negotiating session in Palm Springs in 1980. The players and owners would play chicken right up to an in-season strike deadline before agreeing to push the dispute back to 1981. That year, of course, was interrupted by the two-month strike, but an agreement was reached in time to stage a complicated split-season playoff format that, curiously, left out a Cincinnati Reds team that had the best overall record in either league.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

For a time, it seemed as if both sides had learned their lesson. The next decade or so saw a couple of CBA’s negotiated without any significant in-season impact, and the owners and players tweaked the compensation system to provide some modest help for struggling small-market teams.

Then came the great labor war of 1994-95, which stretched so long that I covered negotiations in a couple dozen cities (not necessarily different cities) and rolled up enough airline and hotel points to take my family to Hawaii … twice. If there had been a Sapphire Reserve Credit Card in those days, I could have retired on a cruise ship.

Of course, the strike/lockout took a big chunk out of the 1994 season, canceled the World Series, delayed the start of the 1995 season and alienated millions of fans. Many of whom did not come back until after Cal Ripken Jr. healed the game one autograph at a time on his way to breaking Lou Gehrig’s consecutive games record and the steroid era made baseball more exciting than it is now.

The owners and players really did get religion after that and Manfred won a big enough place in the hearts of Commissioner Bud Selig and the hardline owners to eventually take charge of the whole operation. Who knew that he would also eventually decide that the owners were on the right side of history when they attempted to impose a salary cap on the players in 1995 and were slapped down by future U.S. Supreme Court justice Sonya Sotomayor.

It’s still my opinion that Sotomayor was wrong on the law when she struck down the owners’ declaration of an impasse in the negotiations. The dispute had been so immovable that not even President Bill Clinton could talk both sides into a compromise.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

But time passes and all those hundred-millionaires who owned baseball teams back then don’t own them now, so there really is no one on the management side – except Manfred – to remember how painful and damaging that work stoppage was. Now, there’s a new group of billionaires who aren’t used to having their employees tell them no.

Manfred obviously won’t … at least for now. He just sent a message to the players to hunker down, because it’s going to be a long winter and maybe a short spring.

The timing of the likely lockout date is obvious for a couple of reasons. It coincides, of course, with the expiration of the current labor agreement, though the terms of that agreement remain in place until a new agreement is signed or successfully imposed. It also creates time, at least theoretically, for the players who are not under contract for 2027 to get uncomfortable with the uncertainty of it all.

It remains to be seen if the players’ union is as strong and unified as it was in the 1990s, but it’s not as if the players are going to be missing any paychecks unless the work stoppage stretches into April.

Generally, they get all of their annual salary over the six months of each regular season, and even the minimum salary guys earned over $700,000 this past season, so nobody’s going to have to shop at Costco unless they really enjoy having a garage full of toilet paper. Like I do.

I still believe, as I wrote a month or two ago, that the negotiations will drag into February and the owners will lift the lockout and allow the 2027 season to be played before blowing up the sport a year from now.

Maybe both sides will have come to their senses by then.

Scroll Down to LEAVE A COMMENT

Peter Schmuck

Share
Published by
Peter Schmuck

Recent Posts

  • Rich Dubroff

Orioles receive reliever Carter Baumler back from Rangers, claim right-hander Braden Nett from Athletics

The Orioles have received right-hander Carter Baumler from the Texas Rangers. Baumler, who was a…

November 19, 2026
  • Rich Dubroff

Sifting through possible free-agent starters for Orioles

The starting pitching market is heating up. On Wednesday, the Minnesota Twins signed Sonny Gray,…

November 19, 2026
  • Mailbag

What’s the Orioles’ offseason strategy? | MAILBAG

Question:  Do the Orioles have an actual strategy for building the team? First, they failed…

November 19, 2026
  • Rich Dubroff

Orioles announce uniform changes, alternative on-field cap

The Orioles are changing their uniforms for the 2027 season, adding an alternative on-field cap…

November 18, 2026
  • Minors

Orioles add intriguing prospects to 40-man roster

Two weeks from now, Major League Baseball is expected to begin a lockout. Ahead of…

November 18, 2026