Mailbag

What’s the Orioles’ offseason strategy? | MAILBAG

Question:   Do the Orioles have an actual strategy for building the team? First, they failed to extend Trevor Rogers; then they signed Rece Hinds to a contract only to cut him less than two weeks later. No one in their right mind thought Hinds was a suitable backup outfielder. If they wanted to play a potentially poor-fielding outfielder, Coby Mayo could play that role. At least he can hit. Now, there’s news of possible interest in a 33-year-old infielder while the O’s have an overabundance of infielders. Perhaps they are thinking of bundling some of the other infielders for pitching or outfield help? I’d like to think that’s the case, but based on previous moves, I’d doubt it. These are just some examples of what I consider head-scratching moves. Thoughts? From: Mike Webb

Answer: Mike, I was in favor of the Orioles signing Trevor Rogers to an extension during the season, so we’ll see what happens with him.

Let’s revisit this question in two weeks since I think the bulk of the Orioles’ offseason moves will come before the expected lockout hits.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Most of the rumored trades and free agent signings don’t pan out, and I think you should look at the offseason as a whole and not focus on individual moves.

I was also surprised by the Rece Hinds re-signing, but since he has an opportunity in South Korea, it turned out to be unimportant.

On the surface, the interest in Ketel Marte looks odd, but I’m willing to wait until December 2nd to assess moves. There is not likely to be much time between the time a Collective Bargaining Agreement is completed and spring training begins, so most of the moves will happen before then. 

Question:  I am totally confused by the MVP voting, Pete Alonso finished fifth, Junior Caminero finished second, if you compare their statistics, they’re almost identical, you could even actually say Alonso’s stats were better and Alonso’s stats were significantly better than Bobby Witt Jr.’s, not to mention playing a gold glove caliber first base and the leadership he provided off and on the field. From: Ken Truckenmiller

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Answer: Ken, I was not a voter for Most Valuable Player this season, but if I were, I would have voted Alonso fourth behind Yordan Alvarez, Junior Caminero and Bobby Witt Jr.

Caminero’s offensive stats were very close to Alonso’s, but he was the best player on Tampa Bay, which had the best record in the American League during the regular season, and that’s important.

His WAR (Wins Above Replacement) was 5.8, which was higher than Alonso’s 5.0, and Caminero’s defensive WAR .8 was while Alonso’s was -.9. Many voters look carefully at WAR before making their choices.

Witt did play for a team that lost 93 games, but he had an excellent season with a 6.7 WAR, including a 1.7 WAR at shortstop. He also stole 45 bases in 53 tries.

The Orioles were on the fringes of the postseason, and Alonso was clearly the best player on the team. However, I’m convinced that Alvarez, Caminero and Witt were all more valuable.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

The Yankees’ Cam Schlitter finished fourth, and I think Alonso should have been ahead of him. If the Orioles play better in 2027, and Alonso has another strong year, I think he could be a genuine contender for MVP.

Most weekdays, I’ll be answering at least one Orioles question. If you’d like to submit a question, send it to: Rich@BaltimoreBaseball.com. Questions may be edited for clarity, length and style.

 

 

Scroll Down to LEAVE A COMMENT

Rich Dubroff

Rich Dubroff grew up in Brooklyn as a fan of New York teams, but after he moved to Baltimore, quickly adopted the Orioles and Colts. After nearly two decades as a freelancer assisting on Orioles coverage for several outlets, principally The Capital in Annapolis and The Carroll County Times, Dubroff began covering the team fulltime in 2011. He spent five years at Comcast SportsNet’s website and for the last two seasons, wrote for PressBoxonline.com, Dubroff lives in Baltimore with his wife of more than 30 years, Susan.

Share
Published by
Rich Dubroff

Recent Posts

  • Rich Dubroff

Sifting through possible free-agent starters for Orioles

The starting pitching market is heating up. On Wednesday, the Minnesota Twins signed Sonny Gray,…

November 19, 2026
  • Rich Dubroff

Orioles announce uniform changes, alternative on-field cap

The Orioles are changing their uniforms for the 2027 season, adding an alternative on-field cap…

November 18, 2026
  • Minors

Orioles add intriguing prospects to 40-man roster

Two weeks from now, Major League Baseball is expected to begin a lockout. Ahead of…

November 18, 2026
  • The Bird Tapes

Bird Tapes Mini-Pod: What I Wrote When Camden Yards Opened

The roar of a sellout crowd sent my imagination soaring. Hear me read what I…

November 18, 2026
  • Minors

Orioles add 7 players, including Bradfield, to 40-man roster

The Orioles added seven players to their 40-man roster on Tuesday, protecting them from a…

November 17, 2026