May 20, 2026; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Baltimore Orioles second baseman Jackson Holliday (7) reacts after striking out against the Tampa Bay Rays in the seventh inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Nathan Ray Seebeck-Imagn Images
Orioles broadcaster Jim Palmer pitched 211 complete games in his Hall of Fame career, and he just completed my thoughts on second baseman Jackson Holliday, who doesn’t turn 23 until December 4th.
After a report that the Orioles had interest in Arizona’s Ketel Marte — who’s coming off a down season, is 33 and gets mixed reviews in the clubhouse — some fans and media members expressed excitement about a 2027 infield of Pete Alonso, Gunnar Henderson, Jordan Westburg and Marte, a three-time All-Star. Palmer mentioned an ’80s show known for its style to say something of substance:
As Sonny Crockett used to say on Miami Vice when people would drone on about nonsense. Noise Pollution … that’s my take on the hot stove media that crow Jackson Holliday is a bust … only 1200 plate appearances, hamate bone injury, wrist surgery in 2026 and the jury has already decided … capital PLEASE … happy Turkey day to you all.
It was a nice touch for Palmer to add the holiday while defending Holliday, who tried to play through injury last season. After having hamate bone surgery on his right wrist, he had to shut down his rehab assignments twice because of pain. When he joined the Orioles in mid-May, manager Craig Albernaz used him as a platoon player before putting him in the everyday lineup. Holliday heated up in July, batting .368 with a .921 OPS, before slumping badly in August and getting shut down again in September. Late in the month, he had surgery on his left wrist.
The oft-injured Westburg needed Tommy John surgery and was out for the season. The 27-year-old isn’t facing the same scrutiny even though he’s missed 388 games in his four seasons. There isn’t a need to compare the two — Holliday was the first pick in 2022, Westburg the 30th pick in 2020 — but it does seem misguided to be so eager to get back one while seemingly dismissing the other.
Which turns my thoughts to Mike Elias’s draft choices and the faith the president of baseball operations might still have in them. Last season’s trade of catcher Adley Rutschman seemed to be an acknowledgement that he didn’t think he’d be able to re-sign Rutschman when he becomes a free agent after the 2027 season. Elias wanted to get value for Rutschman during a second straight down season for the Orioles. It also might have been an admission that he should have taken Bobby Witt Jr. with the first pick in the 2019 draft.
At the time of that draft, I thought there was wisdom in Elias’s choice because he took shortstop Gunnar Henderson in the second round. Rutschman provided an immediate impact when he made his debut in 2022, leading the Orioles to a winning season after they had lost more than 100 games in three of previous four seasons. Henderson also contributed when he arrived at the end of August.
They both were stellar in 2023, when the Orioles won the AL East and 101 games, and in the first half of 2024, when the Orioles were considered the best team in baseball at the All-Star break. I thought Rutschman would become the best catcher in Orioles history, and that Henderson would become one of the team’s best all-time players.
Now, Rutschman is with the Red Sox and Henderson hasn’t been the dynamic player he was in ’23. His agent is Scott Boras, who encourages his players to explore the free-agent market. Henderson will be a free agent after the ’28 season, and if Henderson and the Orioles struggle again in ’27 season before the trade deadline, Elias will have another difficult decision to make.
But assuming Major League Baseball doesn’t take away the sport from the fans in ’27 because of a labor dispute, Elias’s young core could justify his belief in them. I’m talking about Henderson, Westburg, Holliday, Cowser, and Samuel Basallo. Coby Mayo appears to have accomplished that with his breakout season in ’26.
Other than Mayo and Westburg, whose right-handed bat has been missed along with a grit that contradicts his injury history, the other four — Henderson, Holliday, Cowser and Basallo — are left-handed hitters with a propensity to strike out, especially against left-handed pitchers. It’s why Cowser, their best outfielder, was replaced too many times by the switch-hitting Leody Taveras. It’s why Jeremiah Jackson was taking away time from Holliday. It didn’t apply to Henderson and not as much to Basallo, but all four had disappointing seasons.
A team that had a wonderful season, the Milwaukee Brewers, won the World Series with five left-handed hitting starters — Jake Bauers, Christian Yelich, Brice Turang, Garrett Mitchell and Sal Frelick. They also had a starter who could throw 103 mph and a shutdown bullpen, but their left-handed hitters impressed in the way they put the ball in play. Manager Pat Murphy got buy-in from all of his players. When the Brewers played the Dodgers in the National League Championship Series, he said they have Hall of Famers, and we have gamers. They proved it over and over again in the postseason, going 11-2 and dominating the Tampa Bay Rays in the World Series.
The night after they clinched the Series, they carried the championship trophy into Lambeau Field and Frelick did a Lambeau leap. We haven’t experienced that kind of joy since Delmon Young’s postseason double against the Tigers in 2014.
But I still contend there’s untapped talent in Elias’s choices and that some bounce-back seasons could make a big difference, especially if Albernaz has a better second season by relying less on platooning and more on his regulars. And by showing he has their back in all circumstances.
Elias miscalculated by not signing left-handed starter Trevor Rogers to an extension, a head-scratching oversight. He also shouldn’t have given up on right-handed starter Grayson Rodriguez, who was traded for outfielder Taylor Ward last season. Ward was a bust, and although Rodriguez struggled, the potential is still there.
I feel the same way about the core players and am hoping with a stronger focus on development from general manager Jared Banner, they’ll be given one more chance to prove their worth.
Despite the near certainty of a lockout 10 days from now, the Orioles continued to…
As expected, the Orioles tendered 2027 contracts to infielders Gunnar Henderson, Jordan Westburg and outfielder…
The Orioles and closer Félix Bautista agreed on a one-year contract for the 2027 season,…
So, on December 1st, Major League Baseball is expected to declare a lockout in hopes…
The Orioles have received right-hander Carter Baumler from the Texas Rangers. Baumler, who was a…