Peter Schmuck

Peter Schmuck: Fire the manager? The general manager? And what then?

It’s that time of a bad year again. The Orioles are in a tailspin and the natives are understandably restless.

Trouble is, there is no short-term solution to the problems that this team is experiencing. There is no magic bullet that will lay low the rest of the competition and allow the Orioles to rise from the ashes of a terrible quarter season.

So what happens? The internet is awash in demands for new leadership, and to what end?

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Should the O’s fire Brandon Hyde and punish him for his inability to invent a new form of Tommy John surgery that only requires 15 days on the injured list? Or for only having the most wins in the American League the past two years instead of the whole sport? Or for winning a Manager of the Year award for only two of the past three seasons?

And how about Mike Elias? What, for conducting a near-perfect rebuilding project and filling the roster with a bunch of bright young stars who are having trouble dealing with a form of failure that none of them have ever experienced before?

Which one of them is to blame for not tackling Colton Cowser before he could stupidly dive into first base and tear up his thumb? Which one of them shook Grayson Rodriguez’s hand too hard when he arrived at spring training?

But we’re at the quarter pole of this season and even if you brought Connie Mack back from the dead the reasons for the Orioles’ horrible start are not going to be magically corrected before nature takes its course with the injured players and maturation works the same magic with the young, struggling hitters and fill-in starting pitchers.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Do you know what you get when you blow up the front office after two straight playoff seasons? You get 1998 through 2011. The team got on a managerial merry-go-round and fell victim to mercurial ownership and now we’re blaming Hyde and Elias for the Orioles not making it to the World Series since 1983.

Guess what? I don’t think the Orioles will recover from this start and reach the playoffs, but I do think this team is still bound for eventual glory if somebody doesn’t throw the baby birds out with the bathwater. Sorry for editing that time-worn cliché but it’s a cliché because history has proven that it’s the best way to illustrate this kind of situation in the fewest possible words.

There’s still plenty of enjoyment to be had from this season. Those convalescing players will come back from the IL. Those young hitters are beginning to show signs of the greatness they might express over the coming years. I’m guessing the second half of the season will be much better than the first, which will carry the team into 2026 with renewed hope for a deep playoff run.

The postseason is not an impossibility this year. The Orioles would have to gain 10 games on .500 by mid-July to set up for a healthy finish, but that is a very big ask with the way they are playing right now.

I’d like to keep the faith, but I’m a bit of an agnostic at the moment.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

 Scroll Down to ** LEAVE A COMMENT **

Peter Schmuck

Share
Published by
Peter Schmuck

Recent Posts

  • Rich Dubroff

Orioles re-sign Albert Suárez to minor league contract

After declining to offer him a major league contract last month, the Orioles have re-signed…

December 17, 2025
  • Rich Dubroff

Free-agent starting pitching options for Orioles

The Orioles began selling Pete Alonso jerseys on Monday for fans eager to wear No.…

December 17, 2025
  • The Bird Tapes

Lost Voices: Joe Ginsberg

When I interviewed Brooks Robinson for my book on Orioles history in 1999, he turned…

December 17, 2025
  • Rich Dubroff

Manager Craig Albernaz puts together a mix of old and new for his 1st Orioles’ staff

Orioles manager Craig Albernaz’s first staff is nearly complete. There are 11 confirmed coaches, four…

December 16, 2025
  • Mailbag

Can Orioles’ outfielders help them contend in 2026? | MAILBAG

Question: Thanks for gently letting down the fan who wanted to compare Pete Alonso to…

December 16, 2025
  • Rich Dubroff

Pete Alonso reveals reasons for joining Orioles: ‘This partnership to me it was just head and shoulders above everybody else’

On Friday, Pete Alonso spoke at length about what attracted him to the Orioles and…

December 15, 2025