Orioles

Peter Schmuck’s Short Take: Not the right time for Holliday

Like everyone else, I can’t wait to see super prospect Jackson Holliday in a major league uniform, but now is not the time.

Orioles executive VP/general manager Mike Elias hasn’t entirely ruled out adding the shortstop to the late-season roster, so it certainly has to seem like an exciting possibility for a rejuvenated fan base that would love to see him in September.

The 19-year-old wunderkind has absolutely dominated minor league pitching at three levels and was recently promoted to Triple-A Norfolk, leaving him one step away from a meteoric rise to the big league roster, but there are all sorts of reasons why that should not happen until next season.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

For one, Holliday might be as much a distraction as an attraction on a team that is barreling toward the playoffs and – at least at the moment – doesn’t really have room for another terrific young infielder.

The kid could be ready. He could be one of those once-a-decade Ken Griffey Jr. types who can play like a superstar while still in his teens, but there is no need to try to figure that out during the last week or two of a season that couldn’t have gone better for last year’s top overall draft choice – or the O’s, for that matter.

He needs to go home bathed in the glow of being named the team’s Minor League Player of the Year in his first full professional season. During his climb through baseball’s top farm system, Holliday (through Thursday) has amassed 505 plate appearances and batted .325 with a .444 on-base percentage, a .506 slugging percentage and a OPS of .950.

No sense taking the risk of him leaving this season with any doubt in his mind about his readiness for the major leagues. That’ll be the hot topic next spring, when the team can determine whether he’s really ready for prime time and likely will have more room for him on the currently crowded infield depth chart.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

The kid will be in the picture soon enough.

Scroll Down to LEAVE A COMMENT

Peter Schmuck

Share
Published by
Peter Schmuck

Recent Posts

  • Rich Dubroff

Game 2: Young allows 10 runs as Orioles lose ‘ugly’ to Astros, 11-5

BALTIMORE--What happened? After beating the Houston Astros, 10-3, behind two grand slams and strong pitching…

April 30, 2026
  • Rich Dubroff

Game 1: Rutschman, Jackson hit grand slams to back Bassitt’s strong performance in 10-3 win over Astros

BALTIMORE--What happened? Veteran right-hander Chris Bassitt hadn’t been happy with how the Oriole starters had…

April 30, 2026
  • Rich Dubroff

Flu sends Rogers to injured list; Orioles-Astros lineups for Game 1

BALTIMORE—Orioles left-handed starter Trevor Rogers will miss two starts because of the flu, manager Craig…

April 30, 2026
  • Calling the Pen

Calling the Pen: Breakthrough for Orioles’ Baz and a powerful sign from Alonso

There was a lot to unpack from Tuesday night's Orioles-Astros game, but baseball seldom pauses…

April 30, 2026
  • Mailbag

Should you be optimistic about the Orioles? | MAILBAG

Question: No offense, Rich, but you are delusional if you don't think the Orioles' results…

April 30, 2026