Dan Connolly

Judge beats out Benintendi and Mancini — who finishes third — for AL Rookie of the Year

No surprise.

All rose for the Judge

New York Yankees outfielder Aaron Judge was the unanimous selection Monday for the American League Rookie of the Year Award, being named first by all 30 Baseball Writers Association of America voters.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Judge hit 52 homers for the Yankees, setting a record for most longballs for a rookie. He is also a legitimate candidate for AL MVP, which will be announced Thursday on MLB Network.

Judge beat out Boston outfielder Andrew Benintendi, who finished second with 75 points (23 second-place votes and six, third-place votes) and the Orioles’ outfielder/first baseman Trey Mancini, who placed third with 31 points (five, second-place votes and 16 third-place ones).

Also receiving votes were Oakland’s Matt Olson, Houston’s Yuli Gurriel and the Yankees’ Jordan Montgomery.

Mancini, who hit .293 with 24 homers while playing left field for the first time as a pro, becomes the first Oriole to finish in the Top 3 in Rookie of the Year voting since Daniel Cabrera in 2004. The Orioles haven’t had a winner since closer Gregg Olson in 1989.

CONTINUE READING BELOW

Mancini appeared on the awards show Monday and gave credit to manager Buck Showalter and his veteran teammates for helping him maintain consistency throughout the season. He specifically mentioned catcher Caleb Joseph for his help in 2017.

Mancini, a Notre Dame product, was an eighth-round pick in 2013 – the same draft in which Judge was selected 32nd overall.

The Los Angeles Dodgers’ Cody Bellinger was the unanimous winner in the National League.

Scroll Down to LEAVE A COMMENT

Dan Connolly

Dan Connolly has spent more than two decades as a print journalist in Pennsylvania and Maryland. The Baltimore native and Calvert Hall graduate first covered the Orioles as a beat writer for the York (Pennsylvania) Daily Record in 2001 before becoming The Baltimore Sun’s national baseball writer/Orioles reporter in 2005. He has won multiple state and national writing awards, including several from the Associated Press Sports Editors. In 2013 he was named Maryland Co-Sportswriter of the Year by the National Sportscasters and Sportswriters Association. And in 2015, he authored his first book, "100 Things Orioles Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die." He lives in York, with his wife, Karen, and three children, Alex, Annie, and Grace.

View Comments

  • A lot of exciting talent in this year’s ROY finalists. Congrats to Mancini for the determination and work he put in to wind up there, against any reasonable expectation. Here’s hoping he has a very long and very productive future with the Orioles!

  • So did Benintendi actually garner more votes or did Judge win unanimously and the next 2 were just announced alphabetically?

Share
Published by
Dan Connolly

Recent Posts

  • Spring Training

Rogers allows 6 runs in Orioles’ 8-5 loss to Team Netherlands; Albernaz: ‘Sloppy game’

SARASOTA--What’s happening? After a day off on Monday, the Orioles played a game that didn’t…

March 3, 2026
  • Spring Training

Orioles make 1st cuts, optioning McDermott, sending 4 others to minor league camp

SARASOTA—The Orioles made their first cuts of spring training on Tuesday, optioning right-handed pitcher Chayce…

March 3, 2026
  • Spring Training

Orioles on World Baseball Classic: ‘Once-in-a-lifetime opportunity’

SARASOTA—Nine players from the Orioles are set to play in the World Baseball Classic. Three…

March 3, 2026
  • Mailbag

Will the Orioles platoon Dylan Beavers? | MAILBAG

Question: I am wondering how you think playing time gets sorted out in the Orioles'…

March 3, 2026
  • Spring Training

Projecting the Orioles’ Opening Day roster midway through spring training

SARASOTA—The Orioles have a day off on Monday, and with players heading to the World…

March 2, 2026
  • Mailbag

Why wouldn’t Orioles be interested in Danny Coulombe? | MAILBAG

Question: I still don’t understand why the O’s let Danny Coulombe walk in the first…

March 2, 2026